Two Strategies Hiring Managers Miss When Sourcing Young Candidates

Bruce Tulgan
March 08, 2023

Bruce Tulgan

Founder of RainmakerThinking, Inc. and Top Expert on Leadership Development and Generational Issues in the Workplace

Whether you are hiring young people on the high end or the lower end of the talent spectrum, my guess is that you need to increase your supply of new job applicants. How can you do that?

 

The first places most managers and organizations go to look for new applicants are the very same places where they've found successful hires in the past. The idea is simple: what's worked for you in the past will probably work for you again. In general, this is a good way to start your talent search. So, if you haven't been tracking where your successful hires are coming from thus far, you should start now.

 

But one potential downside of successful-hire profiling is that repeatedly recruiting from the same sources can lead to a homogeneous population of employees over time and ultimately undermine your efforts to develop a diverse workforce.

 

The other potential downside is a bit more obvious: if you are competing for a limited supply of talent, you had better diversify your sources of potential candidates so you can increase your applicant pool.

 

If step one in a good sourcing process is to look in the same places where you've found successful hires in the past, then step two is to look in places that should be good sources but from which you have failed to find successful people in the past. If you've sought new employees only from top schools, but these sources are not yielding enough applicants, it's probably time to consider looking at the best students from second-tier schools. If you've poached talent only from local big-box retailers in the past, maybe you should consider targeting restaurants. If you've been narrowing your search by one set of criteria, maybe you should open up some new possibilities.

 

Here are two less obvious ways to widen your pool of young candidates.

 

Friend Referrals

Employee referrals are a particularly good way to recruit young workers. Because of their emphasis on personal relationships, young people tend to be especially interested in bringing their personal connections to their work environment. Many HR departments have been tracking and encouraging the "best friend at work" concept, not only as an engagement metric, but also in an effort to appeal to younger workers social networking inclinations.

 

Rest assured, however, that young people will not recruit their friends to come work alongside them if they are unhappy in your organization. Sometimes the most successful young people will do great work for their own personal reasons, even if they are not happy with the job. As one young worker told me about recruiting friends: "They want me to encourage my friends from school to interview here. This place is brutal. Why would I recruit my friends? What kind of friend would I be? I'm just banking as much of their training classes, money, contacts, experience as I can, and then I'm out of here."

 

If your young people don't take you up on the chance to recruit their friends, this is worrisome information to which you must pay attention. It is more powerful data than any employee survey can reveal, I promise you.

 

If you've successfully encouraged your best, happiest young employees to make referrals, congrats! These are several ways to make sure these recommendations result in strong new staff members and a positive experience for the referring employees:

 

  • Make sure referring employees really know your workplace and your expectations as a manager and have demonstrated consistent good judgment. If you want to make employee referrals a productive source of applicants, you must ensure referring employees understand the hiring criteria with crystal clarity. The essential charge for the referring employee is simple: "Knowing what you know about the company, the position, the hiring manager, and our expectations, do you have good reason to think the referred employee is likely to fit in the organization?"
  • Maintain continuous communication with the referring employee every step of the way. You must keep referring employees in the loop when you are communicating with their referred friends or acquaintances. Whether you ask the friend to complete an application, set up an interview, arrange a call-back interview, make an offer, or deliver a rejection, let the referring employee know so they are not caught off guard.
  • Understand the risks of employee referrals. When young people go from working with people they consider just colleagues to working with their friends, it often changes the meaning of the job for one or both individuals. Unfortunately, these strong associations may lead to cliques in the workplace and conflict among employees. Also, even if everything goes well with referrals initially, you might make yourself vulnerable to a dual departure risk if something does go wrong. Although I have observed lots of successful referral sourcing, when I describe the risks of friend-referral sourcing in our seminars, hiring managers sometimes decide the risks outweigh the potential benefits.

 

Tapping Parents, Teachers, and Counselors

Funny enough, our research across the board shows that a low-tech strategy is the best one for diversifying hiring sources: seeking referrals from parents, teachers, and counselors. What can you do to tap this source for your organization or yourself as a hiring manager?

 

Sometimes the most effective referral campaigns are driven by tapping older, more experienced employees for their own children, and their friends. Who knows the organization better than a more experienced employee? And who knows their children best but parents? The same rules apply to parent-employee referrals as to friend referrals: encourage only satisfied employees with good performance records and evidence of good judgment. Ensure that the hiring criteria are crystal clear. And always keep the lines of communication open with both the referring employee and the referred. One more thing to be aware of is to make sure you don't violate any nepotism rules your company has in place.

 

Teachers and counselors of young people are an even better source of referrals because they are more objective. Whether you are hiring employees with high school, college, or graduate degrees, building networks of teachers and counselors who are well respected and dedicated to helping their students is a key strategy when it comes to getting the very best candidates. Of course, you must demonstrate to these teachers and counselors the value proposition of the jobs you offer. And you must convince them that by helping you identify the stars among their students, they too will benefit from a positive reputation among students, parents, their own institutions, and the community of employers for helping students get good jobs.

The post Two Strategies Hiring Managers Miss When Sourcing Young Candidates appeared first on RainmakerThinking.

Bruce Tulgan

Want Bruce Tulgan for your next event?

Find out more information, including fees and availability.
Find Out More
Keep Reading
Two Strategies Hiring Managers Miss When Sourcing Young Candidates
Bruce Tulgan
Bruce Tulgan
March 08, 2023
Whether you are hiring young people on the high end or the lower end of ...
New Podcast - Ask Bruce: How to Survive and Succeed in the New World of Work
Bruce Tulgan
Bruce Tulgan
February 02, 2023
As the forces that drive our work environments, required skills ...
14 Tired Myths About Gen Z for Managers to Replace
Bruce Tulgan
Bruce Tulgan
February 02, 2023
These are some of the things that today's young people are telling us in interviews: ...
Two Strategies Hiring Managers Miss When Sourcing Young Candidates
Whether you are hiring young people on the high end or the lower end of the talent spectrum, my guess is that you need to increase your supply of new job applicants. How can you do that? The first places most managers and organizations go to look for new applicants are the very same places where they've found successful hires in the past. The i...
Read More
New Podcast - Ask Bruce: How to Survive and Succeed in the New World of Work
As the forces that drive our work environments, required skills and job responsibilities continue to shift and evolve, you may be asking yourself, “How can I survive and succeed in this new world of work?” I’m happy to share with you my upcoming new podcast ‘Ask Bruce: How to Survive and Succeed in the New World of Work’, launching on all podcas...
Read More
14 Tired Myths About Gen Z for Managers to Replace
These are some of the things that today's young people are telling us in interviews: "They act like their power is unquestionable, but anyone can be cancelled overnight." "My boss doesn't fully trust me to work from home. What? Like I'm going to pretend to work? I could pretend to work just as easily if I went into the office." "They keep makin...
Read More
What Has RainmakerThinking Been Doing These Past Few Months? Big Updates and Changes!
It’s been very busy and eventful since RainmakerThinking and I last connected with you! With our many ongoing consulting relationships, numerous speaking engagements, trips across the country and internationally, moving, and new additions to our team, there was no drought of excitement From USA to Thailand! I was honored to participate in the...
Read More
The proven basics that will make you a better manager
If you're trying to be a better manager, it's likely you're one of the nearly 90% of leaders who are undermanaging. That's not a judgment, that's just math. Undermanagement is not a sign of laziness, apathy, or ineptitude. Actually, it's quite the opposite. Most undermanagement is the result of bad advice, the constant churn of leadership fads. ...
Read More
Defining careers in today's workplace
Flexible schedules. Remote positions. Temp and contract work. Careers today, especially in the case of Millennials, are a patchwork of short-term and transactional employment situations. Resumes are less likely to feature one or two long tenures at established organizations and far more likely to feature an array of positions, often concurrent w...
Read More
Post-pandemic work: What each generation needs for success
If ever there was a generation-defining 'accident of history', the Covid-19 pandemic is it. Compared to other recent accidents of history--the 2008 recession, 9/11, ongoing war--Covid-19 has directly impacted far more people, of all ages, on a global scale. Quite literally, everyone is going through this together. We are currently experiencing a...
Read More
Employers: Beware the consequences of the overcommitment cycle
If you want to stop turnover and prevent people from quitting, as an employer, you must fight overcommitment syndrome within your ranks. This is the toxic cycle: When an organization is understaffed, the extra work inevitably must fall to someone. Everything is urgent and important. People overextend themselves, committing to too many projects w...
Read More
This is what makes a high-retention manager
Smart employers who want to take control of the resignation wave are dialing into their employer value proposition. What do you have to offer employees in exchange for the great work they do? Are great bosses a benefit of working for you? By now, it's a cliche to say that people leave bad bosses, but the data continues to back this up: according...
Read More
It's true: people are rethinking their priorities when it comes to work
Much has been said about the potential causes of the talent shortages employers are facing in 2021. But what I haven't seen many people saying is what seems obvious to us and many of our clients at RainmakerThinking: priorities are changing. In the wake of a global pandemic, everyone, including the most dedicated and hard-working people, is reth...
Read More