If You Were the PGA, How Would You Fend Off LIV?

Robert Tucker
November 28, 2022

Robert Tucker

Driving Growth Through Innovation

It is one thing to "Monday morning quarterback" the missteps of companies like Kodak, Blockbuster, Nokia, Neiman Marcus and others who were fatally disrupted. It is quite another to put forth what you would do if you were leading an organization in the crosshairs of a disruptive threat, such as the PGA Tour just now.

For those of you who don't follow golf, a few details: In October 2021, Saudi Arabia's sovereign wealth fund suddenly announced formation of a new golf league, LIV (pronounced as in "Live well"), which poses what PGA considers an existential threat to its organization.

Beginning late last year, LIV began secretly poaching players away from the PGA. Signing bonuses and purses far exceeded what even the winningest players received. Tiger Woods turned down a package said to be worth $700 to $800 million; Dustin Johnson signed with LIV reportedly for a hundred and twenty-five million dollars.

As I am addressing a group of golf industry executives next month in, I've been soliciting opinions from friends, family members, and fans regarding this international dust up. In the past, numerous groups (but not LIV) have brought me over to advise them on innovation, and I've seen the role innovation is playing as this epic battle unfolds.

"LIV clearly represents a disruptive threat to the PGA," notes golfer Timothy McQuay, a retired investment banker, and my brother-in-law. "My sense is that they are taking LIV very seriously but are not certain how best to combat it."

No surprise there. My research inside disrupted organizations suggests that, in the fog of war, initial missteps are almost guaranteed. The CEO of Blackberry shrugged off the iPhone as a mere "niche product" and didn't think about it for over a year. Leaders can easily lapse into a state of "denial"; they mask fear by exhibiting hubris; they downplay and underestimate the threat.

For PGA officials, working out your strategy while operating in the fishbowl of media attention is especially unnerving. Overall, golfers I spoke with didn't seem to think the PGA was off to a good start combating the threat.

Colin McQuay, my nephew and also an avid golfer, explained his view: "The PGA has done a very poor job, from a PR standpoint, combating the LIV threat. I was pretty turned off by all the comments made in the early days. They made the PGA seem entitled, anti-golfer, and whiny."

Initial missteps aside, where the PGA-LIV dustup gets interesting is how both leagues recognized the vital role innovation would play from the starting gun.

First, LIV coaxed away players with their innovative business model. They promised payouts, not just to tournament winners, but to all golfers playing in their events. PGA Tour events, while open to anyone who could qualify to play, paid losers nothing in what was long-celebrated as the American-individualist ideal, "the purest form of meritocracy," as one golfer put it. LIV innovated different formats such as shotgun starts and team play in addition to individual play.

All of these moves brought novelty to LIV events and caused some fans to anticipate what PGA Tour might do in response. "This is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to reshape how the PGA Tour operates," Phil Mickelson, one of PGA's biggest stars told Golf Digest.

One of the biggest surprises to me in my casual interviews was how little loyalty the PGA engenders, especially among younger players. LIV's entrance has turned a gentlemanly sport, where members doffed their hats before shaking hands, into a money grab. "I thought golf was supposed to be gentlemanly," one golfer told New Yorker writer Zach Helfand. "All of a sudden they've turned into animals."

Golfers I spoke with were surprisingly neutral on LIV's gambit. Though not fans of Saudi Arabia, especially after the country's ruler ordered the murder and dismemberment of a critic, they turned out not to be diehard fans of PGA Tour either. The fact that PGA Tour makes contributions to local nonprofit entities seemed not to matter as much as one would assume.

Opening skirmishes aside, these are early days. LIV has no television deal, though it's said to be closing in on one with Fox Sports. Where this dogfight will end up is probably a matter of who keeps innovating best for both viewers and players alike.

"If I were the PGA," sums up Colin McQuay, "what I’d be focused on is what LIV could be, and how I beat them to the punch where it makes sense for me (the PGA) to do so. There is no doubt LIV has staying power, and when they do land a major network TV deal, that changes the game for them. But they’ll still have to figure out how to get their golfers to actually care about winning their tournaments though, which to-date, I don’t think they have a great solve for."

I would greatly appreciate and value your thoughts on what PGA Tour might do to best countervail LIV, and wish you a great holiday season. See you next month.

The post If You Were the PGA, How Would You Fend Off LIV? appeared first on Innovation Resource.

Robert Tucker

Want Robert Tucker for your next event?

Find out more information, including fees and availability.
Find Out More
Keep Reading
China's Latest Issue: Nobody Wants To Go There Anymore
Robert Tucker
Robert Tucker
August 17, 2023
Six months after China lifted Covid-19 restrictions and reopened its borders, ...
As Climate Disasters Increase, Here's How One Kentucky Town is Rebuilding
Robert Tucker
Robert Tucker
March 06, 2023
Last week I flew to tiny Dawson Springs, Kentucky, to help rebuild ...
Will Baby Boomers Live Up to Their Potential?
Robert Tucker
Robert Tucker
February 09, 2023
There's an old joke about two babies who were placed side-by-side in a hospital maternity ...
China's Latest Issue: Nobody Wants To Go There Anymore
Six months after China lifted Covid-19 restrictions and reopened its borders, visitors are staying away in droves. The Wall Street Journal reports that Shanghai's and Beijing's airports are nearly deserted. In the first half of 2023 less than a quarter of visitors travelled there compared to 2019. And with foreign investment in China down 80 per...
Read More
As Climate Disasters Increase, Here's How One Kentucky Town is Rebuilding
Last week I flew to tiny Dawson Springs, Kentucky, to help rebuild houses destroyed in the devastating tornadoes that ripped through the state a year ago. As a totally unskilled volunteer for an organization called Fuller Center Disaster ReBuilders, I am not sure I made much of a contribution. But I returned home to California with unexpected jo...
Read More
Will Baby Boomers Live Up to Their Potential?
There's an old joke about two babies who were placed side-by-side in a hospital maternity ward. They lay there staring at one another. Decades later, in their 90s, the two recognized each other when they found themselves sharing the same hospital room. One of them says to the other, "So how'd it go?" These days, the Baby Boom Generation seems ...
Read More
How to Seize the Opportunities in Climate Change
Canadian Wayne Gretzky, the winningest ice hockey player of all time, was once asked the secret of his success. "Simple, he replied. "I don't skate to where the puck is, I skate to where it's going to be." If you're a regular reader of this newsletter, you know our focus is on skating to where the opportunities will be in the future — and positi...
Read More
The Most Important Leadership Mindset Everybody Needs to Master
You don't need a crystal ball to see that we’re in a period of mass acceleration right now. “It’s as if we’re driving the fastest race car ever imagined through unknown, unmarked terrain,” observes Fareed Zakaria in Ten Lessons for a Post Pandemic World. “But we never bothered to equip the car with airbags.” We didn’t get insurance. We have not ...
Read More
Elon Musk's Innovator's Dilemma
I once asked Elon Musk if he ever felt he was spreading himself too thin. This was years ago when we were both speakers at the Economist Innovation Conference at U.C. Berkeley's Haas School of Business. Musk had already gained a reputation for being a serial entrepreneur, and for an incredible work ethic. Seventy-hour weeks were not uncommon. Bu...
Read More
Five Favorite Environments for Unleashing Creativity
If you've participated in one of my workshops, or watched my videos on YouTube, you've heard me riff on the importance of environment in the creative/innovative process. You put a person in one setting - let's say, a basement windowless conference room in the Days Inn — and they underwhelm you with the ideas they come up with. You take that same...
Read More
If You Were the PGA, How Would You Fend Off LIV?
It is one thing to "Monday morning quarterback" the missteps of companies like Kodak, Blockbuster, Nokia, Neiman Marcus and others who were fatally disrupted. It is quite another to put forth what you would do if you were leading an organization in the crosshairs of a disruptive threat, such as the PGA Tour just now. For those of you who don't f...
Read More
Changing the World Depends on How You Think.
Did you notice what just happened? After two tumultuous, tragic years, Covid 19 has finally receded into the background. The crisis is no longer Topic A. Here in California, where I live, the kids are back in school, masks are disappearing in public places; people are getting on with their lives. What a vastly different world we are living in no...
Read More
Stepping off the Hamster Wheel: How to Stay Creative even When You're Insanely Busy
It wasn’t supposed to go like this. After working remote for two years, knowledge workers were said to have learned a lesson. They vowed to never fully and completely get back on the hamster wheel, to take their work-life balance with them back to the workplace. Instead, I’m hearing from managers that the pressure has never been more intense, an...
Read More