Stop and Frisk Decision Based on Tortured Reading of the Constitution

Dick Morris
August 19, 2013

Dick Morris

Leading American political consultant
Law

The U.S. District Court decision striking down New York City’s stop and frisk law may condemn the nation’s largest city to a return to the days of crime and mayhem which preceded the administration of Mayor Rudy Giuliani.

Since 1992, the number of homicides in the Big Apple has dropped from almost 2,000 a year to about 400.

The ability to stop and frisk men lingering on street corners in the middle of the night in high drug and crime areas has played a key element in reducing the murder rate. Particularly in concert with New York’s mandatory minimum three year sentence for possession of an unlicensed, loaded firearm within the city, the law has forced guns off the street and driven down the murder rate appreciably.

To measure the impact of the stop and frisk and mandatory minimum gun sentence laws, compare New York with Philadelphia. Both have lots of poverty — 21 percent in New York and 25 percent in Philadelphia. The per capita police presence in each place is comparable. But Philadelphia, with a population of 1.5 million, had 334 homicides last year while New York, with 8.5 million had only 450.

But the Court decision threatens to take away the weapon that has kept the city free of deadly weapons and to send the gun murder rate skyward again. Liberals who push for gun controls, which do little to stop crime, should be hollering bloody murder (literally) about the court decision which puts guns back on the streets in New York. But they are not. It wouldn’t be fashionable.

More to the point, the unconstitutionality of the stop and frisk law hinges not on the standards police use to conduct searches, but on the number of minorities searched. So even if cops use racially neutral measurements like presence on a high crime corner, dress, the hour of day, but these criteria generate a disproportionate number of black and Latino stop and frisks, they are unconstitutional.

So even if the criteria are constitutional, if the result of their application is disproportionate the demographic concentrations, it violates the constitution, according to the Court. By this logic, the entire criminal justice system is unconstitutional since, while each measure taken by courts, prosecutors, cops, judges, defense lawyers, and juries may pass constitutional muster, the outcome is clearly to convict minorities at a ratio higher than their percentage of the population. Never mind that they commit more of the crimes!

For information on how to book Dick Morris for your next event, visit PremiereSpeakers.com/Dick_Morris.

Source: Leader and Times

Dick Morris

Want Dick Morris for your next event?

Find out more information, including fees and availability.
Find Out More
Keep Reading
Stop and Frisk Decision Based on Tortured Reading of the Constitution
Dick Morris
Dick Morris
August 19, 2013
The U.S. District Court decision striking down New York City's stop ...
Conservative Pundit draws friendly crowd
Dick Morris
Dick Morris
June 25, 2012
Article from The Bakersfield Californian; Written by Steven Mayer Political author and Fox News ...
Dick Morris Reports - Education: Revolution
Dick Morris
Dick Morris
May 02, 2011
For information on how to book Dick Morris for your next event, ...
Stop and Frisk Decision Based on Tortured Reading of the Constitution
The U.S. District Court decision striking down New York City's stop and frisk law may condemn the nation's largest city to a return to the days of crime and mayhem which preceded the administration of Mayor Rudy Giuliani. Since 1992, the number of homicides in the Big Apple has dropped from almost 2,000 a year to about 400. The ability to stop...
Read More
Conservative Pundit draws friendly crowd
Article from The Bakersfield Californian; Written by Steven Mayer Political author and Fox News commentator Dick Morris is known for his bold predictions -- and he didn't disappoint during a stop in Bakersfield Thursday night. Presumed Republican presidential nominee Mitt Romney, Morris told a crowd of more than 200, is going to "demolish" Pre...
Read More
Dick Morris Reports - Education: Revolution
For information on how to book Dick Morris for your next event, visitPremiereSpeakers.com/dick_morris.
Read More
VIDEO: Obama's Momentum Trouble
Is President Obama's momentum slowing down? Political strategist Dick Morris was asked this by Sean Hannity on Fox News' Hannity. Morris, a former advisor of President Bill Clinton and author of the best-selling book Catastrophe, interprets a new poll that says that Obama's approval rating has dipped below 50 percent for the first time. Watch ...
Read More
VIDEO: Is Obama Losing His Core Support?
Is health care eroding President Obama's support with the Democrat Party's base? Dick Morris thinks so. He stopped by The O'Reilly Factor to explain why. Dick Morris is a renowned political strategist and author who's latest book is Catastrophe. For information on how to bring him to your next event, visit www.premierec...
Read More
VIDEO: The Cost of Climate Change
Cap and trade would cause some people's utility bills to double. So says political consultant Dick Morris. On Friday the U.S. House of Representatives passed the Waxman-Markey bill, which would attempt to tackle climate change, but some are concerned about the bill's emissions trading (i.e. cap and trade) provisions. Here what Morris said about...
Read More
Is Obama 'Dressing Up Socialism'?
Socialism is coming, warns Dick Morris. The Republican strategist wrote on DickMorris.com that President Obama's plan to convert government stock in the country's banks from preferred stock to common stock would result in the federal government have a controlling voice these banks. "And whoever controls the banks controls the credit and, theref...
Read More
Column: Obama Needs to Talk the Talk
Published on TheHill.com on Tuesday February 17, 2009 It's rare to criticize a politician for being all action and no talk, but that's one of the big things that's wrong with Obama's battle against the economic crisis. One of the key variants in any stage of the economic cycle is what the president says is happening. If he talks down the econom...
Read More