Blasting the 'Skeptic Environmentalist'

Andrew Winston
April 27, 2009

Andrew Winston

Director of the Corporate Environmental Strategy Project at the Yale Center for Environmental Law & Policy

The following column by Andrew Winston was originally posted at The Huffington Post.

This weekend, the New York Times gave Bjorn Lomborg -- the self-proclaimed "skeptical environmentalist" -- more air time. Lomborg wrote an op-ed that railed against those who want to cut greenhouse gas emissions dramatically. He offered his opinion on a better solution: "make low-carbon alternatives like solar and wind energy competitive with old carbon sources."

As usual, Lomborg sets up a false straw-man to knock down. He says "we are often told that...we must cut emissions immediately and drastically." Then he worries that people just don't get that we actually need to make renewables cheaper. Really? So none of the major environmental NGOs, or country delegations to global climate negotiations, have thought of that? So to tackle obesity we shouldn't just talk about weight, but also about exercising more and eating right? So insightful...

Lomborg has a long habit of tilting at windmills that he mostly imagines. His most famous argument is that we shouldn't prioritize climate change over other pressing social priorities like poverty alleviation -- as if they're all separate. The poorest people in the world are energy poor and don't have access to clean water -- the two biggest environmental challenges of our time. He's always setting up false tradeoffs to establish his more "reaonsable" middleground.

I will say that one overarching aspect of his arguments is important. Of course we should constantly ask ourselves, "What's the cheapest way to solve that problem, and where should we allocate scarce resources?"...

Read the rest at HuffingtonPost.com.

Andrew Winston is the Director of the Corporate Environmental Strategy Project at the Yale Center for Environmental Law & Policy and the author of the upcoming book Green Recovery: Get Lean, Get Smart, and Emerge from the Downturn on Top. For information on how to bring him to speak at your next event, visit www.premierespeakers.com/andrew_winston.

 

 

Andrew Winston

Want Andrew Winston for your next event?

Find out more information, including fees and availability.
Find Out More
Keep Reading
The Wrong Debate on Green Jobs
Andrew Winston
Andrew Winston
October 21, 2010
The following post by Andrew Winston first appeared on TriplePundit.com. Andrew is an environmental ...
The Greening of the Olympic Sponsors
Andrew Winston
Andrew Winston
March 01, 2010
The following was originally published on the Harvard Business Online. Every year, major sporting ...
Small Changes Making a Big Difference
Andrew Winston
Andrew Winston
June 29, 2009
Environmental policy and business expert Andrew Winston recently wrote a column for Harvard ...
The Wrong Debate on Green Jobs
The following post by Andrew Winston first appeared on TriplePundit.com. Andrew is an environmental policy expert who helps companies find sensible, profitable ways to go green. ------------------ In the heated discussions about climate change and the clean tech economy, it's hard to avoid arguing about whether green jobs are "real" or if th...
Read More
The Greening of the Olympic Sponsors
The following was originally published on the Harvard Business Online. Every year, major sporting events get greener and the goals for renewable energy use, carbon-neutrality, or zero-waste get tougher. The Vancouver Olympics which just ended featured a large range of greening activities; the sustainability staff worked on them for years, prod...
Read More
Small Changes Making a Big Difference
Environmental policy and business expert Andrew Winston recently wrote a column for Harvard Business Online about differentiating major changes and incremental changes. When it comes to the revitalizing your business, he argues, the small changes might be just as important as the grand, sweeping ones. Here's an exerpt: At a recent executive ed...
Read More
Blasting the 'Skeptic Environmentalist'
The following column by Andrew Winston was originally posted at The Huffington Post. This weekend, the New York Times gave Bjorn Lomborg -- the self-proclaimed "skeptical environmentalist" -- more air time. Lomborg wrote an op-ed that railed against those who want to cut greenhouse gas emissions dramatically. He offered his opinion on a better...
Read More